A. Relevance to the field of Comparative and International Education and the Global Comparative Education journal; B. Comprehensive Conceptual/Theoretical Framework C. Appropriateness of the Methodology/Approach D. Originality and contribution to the field/new knowledge E. Technical Presentations (e.g. citation style, references) suitability F: Recommendation: -Publishable with minor revision -Publishable after substantial revision -Topic interesting but article not publishable -Rejected